Pin Grading System
Since enamel pins are hand-made and minor variations are normal, the grading system is a common method for communicating a pin's quality. This is a quick rundown of the grading system as I apply it.
Unless otherwise specified, all pins are A grade by default. B grade pins will sometimes be sold at a discount. Please note that in all cases, pin colors may vary slightly from digital proofs or previous runs. Because the enamel colors are hand-mixed, this variation is expected and normal.
A Grade (Standard)
High quality pins with no more than one or two minor imperfections, generally only apparent when closely inspected, such as:
- very small scratches or scuffs
- very small bubbles, stray dust, or stray glitter in enamel
- minor discoloration or scuffs on metal
- low-fill enamel, not too shallow and not in large areas
- slightly uneven glitter placement (not significant/distracting)
- slight variations in metal/line thicknesses
- very small amounts of excess metal on edges
These pins will have at least one more obvious imperfection. They will be easier to spot, but I'll never sell pins with defects that interfere with a design's overall readability. Examples include:
- low-fill enamel in larger areas, significantly shallow
- minor color spills
- significant defects/chipping in metal plating
- significant scratches, scuffs, or dents
- significant amounts of bubbles, stray dust, or stray glitter in enamel
- very uneven glitter placement
- significant amounts of excess metal on edges
- very obvious variations in metal/line thicknesses
- wobbly (but still functional) posts
These pins will have significant defects, such as incorrect colors, inconsistent enamel fills or spills, etc. At this time, I do not sell C grade pins.